Graviton Theory The Quantum of the Gravitational Field

▶ Open interactive ANITEX · equations and animations

This accessible text edition preserves the document's narrative. See the interactive edition for typeset equations, diagrams and playback.

Abstract

The graviton is the hypothetical quantum excitation of the gravitational field in perturbative quantum gravity. In the weak-field approximation, general relativity can be expanded around a background spacetime, and small metric perturbations behave as a massless spin-2 field. Quantization of these perturbations leads to gravitons. This article develops the graviton concept from linearized general relativity, explains gauge symmetry, physical polarizations, field quantization, propagators, coupling to matter, and the relationship between gravitons and classical gravitational waves. It also discusses why individual gravitons are extraordinarily difficult to detect, why perturbative Einstein gravity is not ultraviolet complete, and how the graviton appears in broader approaches to quantum gravity.

Introduction

General relativity describes gravity as the geometry of spacetime: G_+ g_ = 8 Gc^4T_.

Quantum field theory describes interactions in terms of quantized fields. Photons are quanta of the electromagnetic field, while the weak and strong interactions are also described using quantum gauge fields.

This motivates the question: What is the quantum excitation of the gravitational field?

In perturbative quantum gravity, the answer is the graviton.

The graviton is expected to be massless and to carry spin two.

Weak-Field Gravity

Consider spacetime close to flat Minkowski spacetime. Write the metric as g_ = _ + h_, where |h_|1.

Here _ is the Minkowski metric and h_ represents a small gravitational perturbation.

In natural units, a common normalization is =32 G.

The tensor h_ becomes the field that is quantized in perturbative gravity.

Linearized Einstein Equations

Define the trace h=^h_ and the trace-reversed field h_ = h_ - 12_h.

In harmonic gauge, ^ h_=0.

The linearized Einstein equation becomes h_ = -16 Gc^4T_.

In vacuum, T_=0, so h_=0.

This is a relativistic wave equation.

Plane-Wave Solutions

A gravitational-wave solution may be written as h_(x) = _ e^-ik_ x^, where _ is the polarization tensor.

The vacuum field equation gives k^ k_=0.

Thus, E=pc, which is the dispersion relation of a massless particle.

This is the first indication that the quantum of the weak gravitational field should be massless.

Gauge Symmetry

An infinitesimal coordinate transformation, x^ x^+^, changes the perturbation according to h_ h_ - __ - __.

This gauge redundancy removes unphysical components of h_.

Although a symmetric tensor in four dimensions initially contains ten components, constraints and gauge freedom reduce the propagating physical degrees of freedom to two.

Two Physical Polarizations

For a wave traveling in the z direction, the transverse-traceless metric perturbation can be written as h_ij^TT = h_+ & h_ & 0 h_ & -h_+ & 0 0 & 0 & 0 .

The two independent polarizations are h_+, h_.

These are the two helicity states of a massless spin-2 field.

Quantum mechanically, they correspond to graviton helicities =+2,=-2.

Why Spin Two?

A scalar field transforms as spin zero, while the electromagnetic vector potential is associated with spin one.

The gravitational perturbation is a symmetric rank-two tensor: h_.

After imposing the appropriate gauge conditions and removing nonphysical degrees of freedom, the propagating states transform as helicity 2.

Therefore the graviton is characterized as massless spin-2 boson.

This property is deeply connected to the tensor structure and universality of gravity.

The Fierz--Pauli Description

The free massless spin-2 field can be described by the Fierz--Pauli Lagrangian. Up to conventions and total derivatives, it has the form L_FP =& -12 _ h_ ^ h^ + _ h^ ^ h_ &- _ h^_ h + 12 _ h ^ h.

It is invariant under the linearized gauge transformation h_ h_ + __ + __.

The nonlinear completion of a consistently interacting massless spin-2 field is closely related to general relativity.

Quantization

The classical perturbation can be promoted to an operator: h_(x) h_(x).

A mode expansion has the schematic form h_(x) = _=2 d^3k (2)^32_k .

The operators satisfy bosonic commutation relations: = (2)^3 ^3(k-k') _'.

A one-graviton state is k, = a^_k,0.

Its energy is E=.

Graviton Propagator

In a convenient gauge, the momentum-space graviton propagator has the schematic structure D_,(k) = iP_, k^2+i, where P_, = 12 ( __ + __ - __ ) for a commonly used four-dimensional convention.

The pole k^2=0 again reflects the massless nature of the graviton.

Coupling to Matter

At leading order, the graviton couples universally to the stress-energy tensor: L_ int = -2 h_T^.

This is important because T^ contains energy, momentum, pressure, and stress.

Gravity therefore couples to all forms of energy and momentum rather than to a single type of charge.

The universal coupling is one of the fundamental features distinguishing gravity from the other interactions.

From Graviton Exchange to Newtonian Gravity

In the weak-field, low-velocity limit, exchange of a virtual graviton between two masses reproduces the Newtonian gravitational potential: V(r) = -Gm_1m_2r.

Schematically, m_1 virtual graviton exchange m_2.

This is analogous to the way photon exchange reproduces the Coulomb interaction in quantum electrodynamics, although the tensor structure and self-interactions of gravity are substantially different.

Why Gravity Is Always Attractive in the Classical Limit

For ordinary positive-energy nonrelativistic matter, the tensor structure of massless spin-2 exchange produces the familiar attractive Newtonian interaction.

This contrasts with spin-1 electromagnetism, where charges of the same sign repel and charges of opposite sign attract.

The spin of the mediator and the form of its coupling are therefore deeply connected to the macroscopic character of the force.

Graviton Self-Interaction

Gravity itself carries energy and momentum. Consequently, the gravitational field interacts with itself.

Expanding the Einstein--Hilbert action, S_ EH = 2^2 d^4x-g\,R, around flat spacetime gives schematically L = ( h)^2 + h( h)^2 + ^2h^2( h)^2 +.

The first term describes free gravitons.

The remaining terms describe graviton self-interactions.

This infinite nonlinear structure reflects the nonlinear geometry of general relativity.

Gravitons and Gravitational Waves

A classical electromagnetic wave can be interpreted quantum mechanically as a coherent state containing many photons.

Similarly, a classical gravitational wave may be viewed, in the perturbative quantum description, as a coherent state involving a very large number of gravitons.

Thus, classical gravitational wave many-graviton coherent state.

The observation of gravitational waves confirms propagating classical gravitational degrees of freedom predicted by general relativity.

It does not, by itself, constitute the direct detection of individual gravitons.

Energy of a Single Graviton

For frequency f, E_g=hf=.

For example, for a gravitational wave near f=100\ Hz, the energy of one graviton would be approximately E_g 6.610^-32\ J or E_g 4.110^-13\ eV.

This extraordinarily small energy is one reason individual low-frequency gravitons are so difficult to detect.

Why Individual Graviton Detection Is Difficult

Gravity is extremely weak at microscopic scales.

A useful dimensionless gravitational coupling at energy E is _G(E) GE^2 c^5.

Using the Planck energy, E_P = c^5G, this becomes _G(E) (EE_P)^2.

For ordinary particle energies, E E_P, so the quantum gravitational interaction is extraordinarily weak.

This makes the direct detection of a single graviton far more difficult than the detection of a single photon.

Graviton Mass

In ordinary general relativity, the graviton is massless: m_g=0.

A massless graviton propagates at the invariant speed c in vacuum.

Modified-gravity theories can introduce a nonzero graviton mass. A massive spin-2 field would have additional polarization states and a modified dispersion relation: E^2=p^2c^2+m_g^2c^4.

Observations of gravitational-wave propagation and other gravitational phenomena strongly constrain such modifications, but a nonzero graviton mass belongs to theories beyond standard general relativity.

Perturbative Quantum Gravity

The Einstein--Hilbert theory can be quantized perturbatively around a background.

At low energies, this produces meaningful quantum predictions.

However, Newton's constant has negative mass dimension in four spacetime dimensions: [G]=M^-2 in natural units.

Loop diagrams therefore generate increasingly complicated ultraviolet divergences.

The effective Lagrangian takes the form L_ eff = -g .

Einstein gravity is therefore not perturbatively renormalizable as a fundamental ultraviolet theory.

Effective Field Theory Perspective

Nonrenormalizability does not mean that low-energy quantum gravity is meaningless.

General relativity can be treated as an effective field theory when E E_P.

Quantum corrections are then organized as an expansion in powers such as (EE_P)^2.

Therefore gravitons are perfectly useful theoretical degrees of freedom in the low-energy perturbative regime even if a deeper theory is required near the Planck scale.

Gravitons in String Theory

One of the major motivations for string theory is that a graviton-like state appears automatically in the spectrum of a closed quantum string.

The relevant state is massless and spin two.

Schematically, closed string massless spin-2 state graviton.

Thus gravity is not simply added to string theory by hand; a gravitational degree of freedom arises naturally from string quantization.

Gravitons and Emergent Spacetime

The graviton concept is usually introduced by quantizing a perturbation of an already existing spacetime metric.

However, modern quantum-gravity research raises a deeper possibility: spacetime itself may emerge from more fundamental quantum degrees of freedom.

Then the hierarchy could be c Fundamental Quantum Degrees of Freedom Entanglement and Quantum Information Emergent Geometry Metric Field g_ Graviton as a Collective Quantum Excitation

In such a picture, a graviton could be analogous to a phonon.

A phonon is a quantized collective excitation of a crystal rather than a fundamental microscopic particle. Likewise, in some emergent-spacetime frameworks, the graviton could be an effective excitation of a deeper quantum structure.

This analogy is conceptually useful but is not an experimentally established description of nature.

Graviton Versus Photon

lll Property & Photon & Graviton Interaction & Electromagnetism & Gravity Spin & 1 & 2 Rest mass & 0 & 0 in standard GR Classical field & A_ & h_ Source & Electric current & Stress-energy tensor Physical helicities & 1 & 2 Self-interaction & Indirect in QED & Intrinsic and nonlinear Direct single-quantum detection & Routine & Not achieved

Conceptual Structure

[ node distance=10mm, box/.style=draw,rounded corners,align=center,minimum width=48mm,minimum height=9mm, arr/.style=-Latex[length=2mm],thick ] (gr) General Relativity; (weak) Weak-Field Expansion; (h) h_; (quant) Quantization; (grav) Massless Spin-2 Graviton; (qg) Quantum Gravity;

(gr)--(weak); (weak)--(h); (h)--(quant); (quant)--(grav); (grav)--(qg);

The essential chain is g_ = _ + h_ h_ graviton.

What Is Established and What Is Not

Several distinctions are important.

Classical gravitational waves are experimentally established. Linearized general relativity has two tensor polarization degrees of freedom. Quantizing these weak-field modes leads theoretically to massless spin-2 gravitons. Low-energy quantum gravity can be consistently treated as an effective field theory. Individual gravitons have not been directly detected. A complete experimentally verified ultraviolet theory of quantum gravity is not currently known. It is not experimentally established whether gravitons are fundamental particles or emergent collective excitations of a deeper structure.

Open Problems

Important questions include: Can the quantum nature of gravity be demonstrated experimentally? Can an individual graviton ever be detected? Is the graviton exactly massless? What is the ultraviolet completion of graviton interactions? How do gravitons behave near black-hole singularities? What is the relationship between gravitons and holographic quantum information? Are gravitons fundamental or emergent? How does classical spacetime arise from quantum gravitational states?

Conclusion

The graviton is the natural quantum excitation obtained when weak gravitational perturbations are quantized.

The basic mathematical idea is g_ = _ + h_, followed by h_ h_.

The resulting propagating quantum has the defining properties m=0, s=2, =2 in standard perturbative general relativity.

At low energies, the graviton provides a well-defined effective quantum description of gravitational perturbations. At the Planck scale, however, a deeper theory may be required.

This leads to a fundamental question: Is the graviton fundamental, or is it an emergent quantum of spacetime?

9

Einstein1916 A. Einstein, ``The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity,'' Annalen der Physik, 49, 769--822 (1916).

FierzPauli1939 M. Fierz and W. Pauli, ``On Relativistic Wave Equations for Particles of Arbitrary Spin in an Electromagnetic Field,'' Proceedings of the Royal Society A, 173, 211--232 (1939).

Weinberg1965 S. Weinberg, ``Photons and Gravitons in Perturbation Theory: Derivation of Maxwell's and Einstein's Equations,'' Physical Review, 138, B988--B1002 (1965).

Donoghue1994 J. F. Donoghue, ``General Relativity as an Effective Field Theory: The Leading Quantum Corrections,'' Physical Review D, 50, 3874--3888 (1994).

WeinbergQFT S. Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields, Volume I, Cambridge University Press (1995).

Maggiore M. Maggiore, Gravitational Waves, Volume 1: Theory and Experiments, Oxford University Press (2008).